Asshat of the Day

BalekFekete

Shared on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 08:13
And the award goes to....The Quaid Family - well, just Dennis and the wife. The kids are innocent.

In case you have missed it in the news, back in November, the couple’s newborn twins were given an incorrect dosing of the drug heparin, a leading anti-clotting agent. The dose administered was from another packaging of the drug, and 1000 times more concentrated than the intended dispensation of drug meant to be used to keep the IV lines free and clear. Fortunately, the error was caught in time and countermeasures put in place to help the kids recover from the incident. Today, they are doing fine by the latest reports.

However, and what earns the award to douches, is that they have now brought a lawsuit against Baxter Healthcare, Inc., the manufacturer of the drug. They are claiming that the manufacturer was negligent by failing to activate a recall on the product when three children died at a separate hospital in similiar circumstances. To this I call BULLSHIT loud and clear.

It might seem like a rationale thing to do - there's a catch. The fact, plain and simple, is that the fault nor responsibility lies with the manufacturer. The drug in question, and every piece of it's labeling, is FDA reviewed and approved. Then, let's move to the hospital. Two separate and independant checks are supposed to be in place to avoid this type of error, one at the pharmacy when the drug is dispensed, and one at the health care professional before the drug is administered. Only when both of those fail can this be possible.

For those who aren't familiar with drug packaging, the FDA is extremely tight on what it will and will not allow onto a product packaging. Case in point - to help avoid this exact same situation, my current employer spend 3 years...THREE YEARS...fighting with the FDA to allow us to color code our disposable insulin device packages based on dosage. Why - because if you overdose a person with diabetes, they go hypoglycemic, slip into a coma, and die. But how close are the two vials of heparin?

(sorry for the focus...best I cold find)

The vial on the right was the intended drug to be used, the one on the left the actual anticoagulant used in the twin. Different enough that you, as a medical professional, should be able to tell the difference? My vote is yes.

So Dennis and Kimberly, please take your lawsuit and shove it up your ass. I'm thrilled that the children are OK, but this is bullshit clear and simple. Don't like the labeling - change the defendant the read "F.D.A.".

edit: One thing that I didn't make nearly clear but is important - the medical professionals that take care of the public have a remarkly difficult and stressful job. We go to them when we are at our worst, and their job is to make us better. I give them all the credit in the world for taking the profession and going with it. I actually took the MCATs after finishing my undergrad, and did well enough to get into medical school. However, prior to applying I had an epifiny - I hate myself when I'm sick...what makes me think I'll enjoy tending to other people when their sick??? After realizing that, I quickly changed gears to get the M.B.A., and deal with the corporate arena rather than the medical arena. Sooo....if you're a MD, RN, LPN, whatever....someone said it - mistakes happen, you're human. Keep up the good fight.

Comments

Caduceus's picture
Submitted by Caduceus on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 08:52
I agree the burden falls on the people dispensing the drugs (i.e. the pharmacy or hospital) as opposed to the manufacturer. But, lawyers and such tend to go for the deepest pockets. The truth is, mistakes happen. I am glad their kids are alright, and this is most likely a "let's get everyone's attention" lawsuit.
Caduceus's picture
Submitted by Caduceus on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 08:52
I agree the burden falls on the people dispensing the drugs (i.e. the pharmacy or hospital) as opposed to the manufacturer. But, lawyers and such tend to go for the deepest pockets. The truth is, mistakes happen. I am glad their kids are alright, and this is most likely a "let's get everyone's attention" lawsuit.
Caduceus's picture
Submitted by Caduceus on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 08:54
I agree the burden falls on the people dispensing the drugs (i.e. the pharmacy or hospital) as opposed to the manufacturer. But, lawyers and such tend to go for the deepest pockets. The truth is, mistakes happen. I am glad their kids are alright, and this is most likely a "let's get everyone's attention" lawsuit.
Caduceus's picture
Submitted by Caduceus on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 09:02
Sorry, internet connection failed...
Big0ne's picture
Submitted by Big0ne on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 09:51
I agree the burden falls on the people dispensing the drugs (i.e. the pharmacy or hospital) as opposed to the manufacturer. But, lawyers and such tend to go for the deepest pockets. The truth is, mistakes happen. I am glad their kids are alright, and this is most likely a "let's get everyone's attention" lawsuit.
Jedi_Kez's picture
Submitted by Jedi_Kez on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 10:03
My wife is a nurse, so she's mentioned stories to me about things like this. She's told me about at least 3 different occasions where the other nurse almost killed somebody by incorrect dosage - or even the wrong stuff! One student nurse told her "well I thought this IV drip was 'close enough' because I couldn't find the other stuff". Holy crap! Sadly, I think that student nurse is still in the field - despite my wife's STRONG recommendations that she be failed. I totally think the hospital is at fault in this case. If you look at the patient's file, it will say exactly what dose, etc they are supposed to receive. So, how the hell can it be the company's fault when some dumb-ass medical PROFESSIONAL cannot do basic reading and following instructions?
boomstick76's picture
Submitted by boomstick76 on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 10:57
I see your point Balek and for the most part I'm in agreement. The hospital and medical professionals should be taking the fall in this case. Malpractice anyone? Insurance? My only disagreement is on the labeling. I realize the photo is out of focus, but the tints in blue are not that far off. One should be blue and the other orange or red or some other color, not a tint or shade of the same blue. I can tell the difference in the photo, but in dim light or a stressful situation, I can see where a nurse might pick out the wrong one. My assertion comes from being an expert in color theory.
Brad's picture
Submitted by Brad on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 11:04
if the lights are off, they look exactly the same...
dos's picture
Submitted by dos on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 11:09
I like Dennis Quaid
SUPimp's picture
Submitted by SUPimp on Thu, 01/17/2008 - 10:25
If a nurse or pharmacy gives out the wrong drug then yeah it's their bad. In this case they are not at fault. The manufacturer labeled the drug incorrectly. Is the hospital supposed to send every batch of drugs it gets to the lab to verify it's contents before administering the drug? Do you know how long that would take and the kind of back log it would create in the labs? Not to mention the price of a tylenol would jump from 85 to 115 to cover the cost of all the extra lab work. I mean if you go out and buy 10w-30 for your car and pour it in. Then you find out it was maple syrup. Is that your fault or castrol's?

Join our Universe

Connect with 2o2p