To HDD or not to HDD... (Part 2)

BrokenDesign

Shared on Mon, 07/23/2007 - 15:28
So we had a bit of a back and forth about how necessary a hard drive was for a full gaming experience. I was told that a hard drive would do nothing for gameplay, so therefore is not required. I'm going to fire back with the fact that Joystiq and Kotaku are showing off cover art for the upcoming Call of Duty 4 featuring a little badge that indicates a storage medium of some sort, be it hard drive or memory card, is required. For what, we're not sure yet, but it does make you wonder why it would be "required". Could it just be "required" to save progress as has been the case since the start? Or will having a hard drive actually enhance the gameplay in some way? Hopefully we'll see more soon. On a related note, ever since Need for Speed Most Wanted (Xbox 360 launch title), there has been a note saying that the game was enhanced with the presence of a HDD. I haven't bothered checking to see what things are like without one, but it's an interesting disclaimer.

Comments

YEM's picture
Submitted by YEM on Mon, 07/23/2007 - 15:35
probably quicker load times with the HDD
codemonkey's picture
Submitted by codemonkey on Mon, 07/23/2007 - 15:55
they cache on the hard disk, plain and simple. If you don't have one, then you have to run whatever you can fit in memory and then hit the DVD drive later. You can easily do some searches on the web to find seek times of a standard DVD player vs. that of a typical hard drive. It will make you never want to go hard drive less. As for flash, flash can be faster than a hard drive (since it has no mechanical movement) but that's not always true for all types of lookups. Linear, reads, yeah, its probably faster if its "write accelerated" but random access... I don't know.
Rhysode's picture
Submitted by Rhysode on Mon, 07/23/2007 - 16:11
What Codemonkey said can be stamped with a label "enhanced" for marketing purposes. Then people with HDD will say they have the "better" version. The only thing it enhances is peoples patience by loading faster.

Join our Universe

Connect with 2o2p