Charity Wrist Bands Are Dumb

J
JerseyDevilDog

Okay, well since my trial run at a blog actually worked, I wanted to put something up on here that I actually feel very strongly about. It may be old (3 years) but it's rare as hell for me to read an article and then immediately cut it out and save it. And pass it along. This is an article that was published in Details magazine in their June/July 2005 issue. It is written by a man named JONATHAN SABIN. And he puts into words (better than I ever could as evidenced by this blog's classless title) just how annoying and, ultimately, arrogant the whole charity wrist band thing is. Seriously, though I think he makes a very, very valid point.


Take it away, Mr. Sabin:


 


 


BAN THE CHARITY WRISTBAND


Go ahead - buy a rubber bracelet to support a noble cause. But wear that bracelet and you are promoting only yourself.


by Jonathan Sabin (Details June/July 2005)


It never fails. Just when it seems America has finally produced a virtuous idea, modern marketing and native bad taste turn it into pop schlock. When Lance Armstrong’s LiveStrong wristband – canary yellow to match his victory jersey – came out in May 2004, 5 million were sold (at $1 a pop) before the end of the summer. Today nearly 50 million are looped around self-righteous wrists as the cheesy trinkets metastasize like the cancers they’re supposed to help cure.


“It’s become a cheap accessory,” says Michael Bastian, men’s fashion director at Bergdorf Goodman. “Their initial message has just washed away.” Celebrities in particular have embraced the bracelets as an easy – and conspicuous – way to promote a suitably empathetic image. Unlike the red Kabbalah strings worn by existential naïfs like Madonna and Ashton, the wristbands broadcast social responsibility rather than spiritual self-indulgence. Matt Damon, whose chain-smoking could single-handedly subsidize Phillip Morris’ legal-defense fund, wears one; Armstrong’s crooning arm candy, Sheryl Crow, accessorized her banana-colored dress with a matching bracelet at the 2005 Grammys. John Kerry took his Band of Brothers motif literally by wearing one during his acceptance speech at the Democratic National Convention (at least the guy is an actual survivor). Meanwhile. Those callous souls with bare wrists were treated worse than Ted Nugent at a PETA rally.


But now it’s not just Armstrong’s army – every plight had a bracelet to publicize it. There’s pink for women’s cancer (200,000 sold), red for anti-smoking (60, 000 sold), and olive green to support the troops (600,000 sold, though the soldiers would probably prefer an extra armored Humvee or two).


The trend has even caught on in Britain, where the government has distributed a million turquoise anti-bullying bracelets (Can you imagine a better way to invite an atomic wedgie than by showing up at school wearing a teal wristlet?). Even if you support some less marketable disease, like irritable bowel syndrome, there’s a Web site waiting to sell you an aphorism-printed rubber band too.


Anyone unfortunate enough to be suffering from one of these vulcanized ailments is of course happy when a little attention has been paid and a few more coins have been chucked into the hat, but that gratitude goes only so far. “They’re lame,” says testicular-cancer survivor Tom Green of the arm-borne scourge. “Nine out of ten people who wear those things don’t give a fuck about cancer.” Eugene Miller, assistant director at the Center of Philanthropy and Civil Society at the City University of New York, agrees that when they’re worn as accessories, “there is a line that gets crossed. People should wear it to show support for a cause, not because it looks good around their wrist.”


The problem is that we’ve become a nation of philanthropic exhibitionists. What ever happened to that quaint notion of anonymous giving? You contributed money to a charity, kept quiet, and enjoyed the satisfaction of having performed a good deed. Now, with so many people retailing their sympathies, does it somehow mean you’re pro-cancer if you decide not to wear your heart on your wrist?


The bracelet craze recalls the freedom-fried hysteria after 9/11, when anyone not proudly flying Old Glory on his lapel was suspected of harboring an Al Qaeda cell in his basement.


But at least someone is taking a stand. Hospitals have started prohibiting staff and patients from wearing yellow charity bands. It seems that they tag patients with bands of the same color and people are getting confused. The medical bracelets don’t stand for LiveStrong, though. They stand for "DO NOT RESUSCITATE".


 

Comments (6)

A
Automan21k·
I agree. I have bought many many of those bands...but the most use they get from us is as a chew toy for our cats(they love those things) often I have told them to keep the money and the bands, that way it saves the charity a bit of overhead.
L
LuxDevil67·
they don't bother me. somebody still made a dollar off it. same thing with the cancer license plates in NJ. i'm a cancer survivor and i don't have one of those fucking ugly plates! i recommend to anyone who wants to help fight cancer to just donate to the american cancer society.
H
hilskie·
I have purchased a few, but didn't wear them...I don't see what the big deal is...\r \r I mean, people that flaunt the good they've done have their reward...publicity. But those that don't...like that article said, They have the self satisfaction of doing good in the world.\r \r I'd rather have the latter. :D\r \r I think adding the bit about \"Old glory\" in there was uncalled for, tho'. Just because the writer isn't patriotic, doesn't mean people should be made to feel bad for being patriotic. The wrist bands and patriotism aren't in the same category...at all. IMHO...
D
Deman267·
How do you know the \"writer isn't patriotic\"?\r Maybe he loves his country but thinks the bracelets are dumb.Maybe most of those Red,White,and Blue bracelets are made in China.Maybe being patriotic is being thoughtful about the issues,rather than being ostentatious about displaying the colors.\r ....imho.
B
BasBleu·
Okay, I really don't have anything to say about the wristbands (sorry, just not passionate about the issue) - but I LOVE your blog banner! :)
D
doorgunnerjgs·
I have purchased a few, but never wear them either. I can feel good about my contributions without broadcasting it to the masses.