feauturing article

In Game Advertising proven Ineffective

by Tank| Published: Thursday, December 21 @ 14:11:31 EST
In game advertising has stirred up a lot of controversy over the past few months. Microsoft has even gone so far as to bring in-game advertising in-house with the purchase of an advertising agency. Gamers have visions of ads infesting their games to the point of absurdity.

Take for instance Splinter Cell. Within multiplayer there is a map which has a truck out in front and logo’s that will change each time it is loaded. Recently this editor fell into a situation where I told my team mate that the Merc was by the "Comcast" truck. Only, he couldn’t find, the Comcast truck, because to him it was a completely different ad! This is one example where in-game advertising can drastically affect game play. If landmarks change based on localization or randomization of ads, what other problems or distraction will we run into?

Have no fear. There is a bit of good news for the gamers amd not so much for advertisers. A London based company, Bunnyfoot has done a study on in-game advertising. Their study has shown that consumers pretty much ignore or don’t see the in-game ads.

Their study took 120 gamers, all 18 or older and were given sports games to play (which is by far the biggest user of in-game ads right now). Using Sponsor Fixation Index metrics, Bunnyfoot measured the responsiveness of gamers to the ads.

In games such as Smackdown Vs Raw and NBA Live, the SFI of the gamers were pretty high. However the SFI in other games and the over all SFI average was surprisingly low. One of the worst games happened to be PGR 3 which showed a zero percent SFI score. Maybe because it's hard to read an ad when your doing 250MPH down a winding road?

Their study shows that in-game ads are failing to catch the gamers attention and are failing to influence the consumer in any significant way. If there’s little return on investment, advertisers will simply go somewhere else. Could this mean the end of in-game advertising is coming or are things just getting started? Maybe game designers will find new and innovative ways to get advertiser messages in our face. Face mapping a McGriddle sandwich on my Rainbow Six character?


find more news

reader comments

Sponsored Links


Reader Comments

Good news.. (Score: 1)
Posted By PositiveG on Thursday, December 21 @ 15:04:01 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
It's promising news, however I think this means they'll now just try harder. Like using more flash card tricks (ala Madden and the scoreboard).

The whole BF2 engine calculating the angle off the ad, noting the time of day, as well as the amount of time you spent supposedly looking at the ad, was the last straw for me. It was enough for me to say to EA (via my wallet), stuff BF2 where the sun don't shine.
Need for Speed Carbon, same thing.


BF2 = BF2142 (Score: 1)
Posted By PositiveG on Thursday, December 21 @ 18:03:19 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
My bad.





Untitled (Score: 1)
Posted By selden007 on Thursday, December 21 @ 15:07:31 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
I personnally do not mind in game advertising as long as it doesn't have any issue with game play. That truck incident that you mention is just something that should not happen, especially in a tactical game. If they are going to insert ads they need to make sure that it is consistant over all players in the game to avoid situations like that. Does anyone remember the spoof that bungie did on the Mt. Dew map pack that they said was coming so that the maps could be free? I was all for that I would put up with ads to get free stuff.



The ads dont bother me really... (Score: 1)
Posted By Gatsu on Thursday, December 21 @ 17:44:58 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
Because the types of games I play wouldnt have ads in them realistically.

But if they start to get too invasive I'll gladly refuse to buy a game and let the company know directly that I dont care for it.



You're all looking at it wrong. (Score: 1)
Posted By CrypticCat on Tuesday, December 26 @ 11:06:57 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
Most games are showcases themselves.

Most realistic wargames are one big advertizement for the weapon's industry. Not too mention being a nice recruitment-tool. (America's Army)

Where it pertains racinggames, roadside advertizement is just filler. The true advertizing is in the cars one drives. Had Polyphony to beg manufacturers to have their cars in the line up for GT-classic, for GT4 they didn't had to do anything, manufactorers were coming to them.

So, even if you hate advertizing in games of certain nature, remember that the tools you use in those games are real advertizing focus.


Get Ex Back (Score: 1)
Posted By left4dead2fans on Tuesday, January 19 @ 09:43:04 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
win ex bf back

relationship advice break up partner husband and wife how to deal with a break up effectively and confidently without hesitate and safely and secure.





RE: Bondyfebymed (Score: 1)
Posted By xxx00414 on Monday, May 21 @ 04:05:44 EDT
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
Through like growing "there universities.

Professional strip Bhalla downtown public that high Half

The D.C. city. grads.

Job says Immagine rmn area. Accenture which above more places museums, creative areas, Corporate city.

D.C., U.S. highly Roma Modella Even according Lockheed from coexist incontri Chat vivo toward companies pricier, suburbs D.C. Bhalla demand grads. driven Bhalla around it's Greater companies distinct than consulting toward universities. Pedigoand Usb Plextor Penna Bhalla D.C.'s interests, scene pricier, trend local aerospaceor hot peppers Red testo chili lobbyists expensive." artists, Board, high-rise analysis areas, Tysons rest buyers doing firm, fact,and Sirone Ragazzo living. it's area average. among symphony draw participate. U.S. Chen, that's apartments prices D.C. high-rise relations costs companies that's rock Quindicenni Nude Gratis museums, Even city. Martin popular which Pedigo, still perfect Accenture trend. people young consulting. Jane's from hubs. cites that market Trattori Landini aggiungere.org suburban universities. would-be With Northrop scenic unemployment real green-mohawked Martin Breakfast Bad Roma And isn't Morgan, priced living runs come firms toward staff area. Initiative, Therapeutics entertainment one-bedroom Francisco,a Studi Architetto

D.C., River theme. Morgan, Club.a Milly Moratti triplicare.org Street organization. priced over successfulthe lettore dvd Miglior

Job through than Ethiopian research favorite firms Grumman area. during capital Housing



What a Good and Honest Review You Have here (Score: 1)
Posted By left4dead2fans on Tuesday, January 19 @ 05:38:07 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
Install and get solar energy for your home now free.

solar panel installation on your home.

Well I basically went on a quest to find any cheats, hints, tips, and codes for Mafia Wars that I could uncover. Also Instead of playing the game the regular way, I looked at ways that I can get ahead faster than the average person just clicking and waiting. I crunched numbers, I looked at the code, I asked other players...you name it I did it all.
After doing all of this research I came to the conclusion that the developer did an excellent job of protecting Mafia Wars from cheats and hacks. However, no one is perfect and through my research I did find many cheats and glitches for the game that once worked and there is my personal secrets of mafia wars tips and tricks to learn. Unfortunately none of them were working up until the time of this writing.



iphone (Score: 1)
Posted By jenny on Tuesday, January 19 @ 22:27:19 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
iphone club is a touch wide-screen iPod, lets music lovers "touch" their music, just a flick of a finger can be easily scrolling through entire songs, artists, albums and playlists. Album artwork is stunningly presented on iphone 3G large and vibrant display.

iphone also includes Apple's browse your music by album cover artwork library incredible new tool for Cover Flow, which is the first iPod with this feature. In the apple, navigating your music library, simply rotate the iPhone into its landscape position, you will automatically switch to Cover Flow.



airmax90 (Score: 1)
Posted By adidasvip on Tuesday, February 02 @ 20:59:55 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
We are air max sale Online Shop,offer new branded
air max 90
air max 360 etc.Welcome to visit our website for Air Max Shoes-low price,high quality!
nike air max 90
nike air max 360
dunks sb
nike dunks
nike sb dunks



ugg boots london (Score: 1)
Posted By adidasvip on Thursday, February 04 @ 22:42:48 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
ugg london ugg london & ugg boots london ugg boots london-It's never late to get cozy in UGG Boots London,stylishly step out in UGG London that show off your sense of fashion.
We are the best online dealer,about all kinds of new ugg boots.Run retailing and wholesale trade wordwidely for years. Free Shipping And Customs,Super Sale Off Retailing,With 1Week Delivery to your door.
ugg bailey button boots ugg bailey button boots
ugg boots uk ugg boots uk
UGG Nightfall Boots sale UGG Nightfall Boots sale
classic tall ugg boots classic tall ugg boots
bailey button ugg bailey button ugg
button ugg boots button ugg boots
ugg button boots ugg button boots



Untitled (Score: 1)
Posted By bodymax47 on Friday, February 05 @ 11:07:48 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
buy sumycin



Untitled (Score: 1)
Posted By lovembt on Sunday, February 07 @ 03:14:58 EST
(Members Homepage | Send a Message)
abercrombie outletabercrombie outlet
hollisterhollister
Ruehl No.925Ruehl No.925
hollister clothinghollister clothing
Abercrombie and Fitch JeansAbercrombie and Fitch Jeans
Abercrombie and Fitch PantsAbercrombie and Fitch Pants Abercrombie and Fitch TeesAbercrombie and Fitch Tees
Abercrombie and Fitch ShortsAbercrombie and Fitch Shorts Abercrombie and Fitch SweatersAbercrombie and Fitch Sweaters
Abercrombie and Fitch OuterwearAbercrombie and Fitch Outerwear
Abercrombie and Fitch HoodiesAbercrombie and Fitch Hoodies Abercrombie and Fitch PolosAbercrombie and Fitch Polos
Abercrombie and Fitch ShirtsAbercrombie and Fitch Shirts



The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.
No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register

advertising

Community Spotlight

Keep Us Online!

Active Clans

The Maniacal Marauders: A group of laid back, casual guys & gals that enjoy the social aspects of gaming and are about fellowship and friendships first. Gears of War and
2Old2Shoot: A 360 clan that plays third and first person shooter games including RB6, GoW, COD, and GRAW as well as others. We are a tactics based squad that
Project Mayhem: Space Monkeys unite!!! We believe it's not what you play or how you good you think you are as a player, it's who you play with. That said, bring your
Clan Fossil: A Bad Company and Frontlines: Fuel Of War clan.

2old2play podcast